Early Sunday morning, clocks sprang forward. Someone forgot to tell the Rangers, who fell back in what was a lost weekend.
In what felt like two must have games, they blew up literally by losing both to teams they’re competing with for the playoffs. Instead of taking care of business, they only got one of four total points against the Senators and Blue Jackets on back-to-back days.
For most of Saturday, the Rangers looked like they were in control at Ottawa. Deadline pickup Carson Soucy put them up when his shot trickled through Linus Ullmark. The Senators came close to tying it on a power play late in the first period. Despite Brady Tkachuk thinking he scored, the puck never crossed the goal line. Unfortunately, Tkachuk would get the last laugh.
Mika Zibanejad put the Blueshirts ahead 2-0 when he took a J.T. Miller feed and beat Ullmark with a good wrist shot from the right circle. Will Cuylle made a nice pass to Miller, who then found Zibanejad for his 14th. It’s absolutely absurd that at this point of the season, Zibanejad only has 14 goals. At least he’s been playing much better.
If there’s been a common theme with this team, it’s that you can never get too comfortable. Whether it’s allowing opponents to score the first goal a dozen times in the first two minutes, or giving up a goal after scoring, the Rangers continue to shoot themselves in the foot. It took only 11 seconds for Tkachuk to tip in a Nick Jensen shot that pulled the Senators within one following the Zibanejad goal. That should have been a warning that trouble was brewing.
With the Sens pushing hard for the tying goal in the frantic third, K’Andre Miller made a good defensive play that led to Jonny Brodzinski quickly finding Artemi Panarin behind the Ottawa defense for a beautiful goal that gave the Rangers a 3-1 lead with 12:52 left. It was a heads-up play from Brodzinski, who continues to play well in whatever role coach Peter Laviolette has him in. Enough can’t be said about how Brodzinski continues to contribute when he’s in the lineup. More often than not, he makes things happen.
For much of the third period, it was relentless pressure from the Sens, who seemed hungrier than our side. They kept coming at the Rangers in waves, which was eerily similar to what the Caps did in a come from behind win in overtime last Wednesday. What was so frustrating is that it felt like the Sens did whatever they wanted in the Rangers’ zone. Particularly directly in front of Igor Shesterkin, who didn’t have his best period.
Juuso Parssinen took a bad hooking penalty that put the Senators on their fifth power play. Although they had trouble executing, eventually taking that many penalties came back to bite the Rangers. Just as Parssinen exited the penalty box, Dylan Cozens got off a backhand in front that hit the goalpost. Ridly Creig then put home the rebound to cut the deficit to one with 9:44 remaining.
The Senators continued to dominate most of the play. Eventually, their strategy of getting traffic in front paid off, which led to them tying the game late in regulation. It was the Shane Pinto line that wreaked havoc, with Michael Amadio getting to a juicy rebound of a David Perron shot and slamming it home with 2:52 left. Neither Braden Schneider nor Urho Vaakanainen were in the right position on the game-tying goal. Vincent Trocheck was in the vicinity along with Panarin. There was a lot of stick checking. Nobody took either Perron or Amadio.
It was inexcusable. Once again, the Rangers blew a third period lead against a feistier opponent who wanted it more. Before it even got to overtime, the Panarin line came very close to winning it. The trio of Panarin, Trocheck, and Alexis Lafreniere had the puck on a string with the Senators chasing. But they couldn’t deliver the knockout blow, with Panarin sending a shot wide.
Overtime didn’t last long. K’Andre Miller was the culprit on Tkachuk’s overtime winner just 33 seconds in. After playing extremely well with partner Will Borgen, Miller rushed a pass to J.T. Miller that handcuffed him. It was a bad pass that went behind Miller, who couldn’t handle the puck. That turnover led to Tim Stutzle retrieving the loose puck and finding a wide open Tkachuk for a wrist shot that went through Shesterkin to help the Senators complete a 4-3 comeback win.
While Miller got roasted for the turnover, he wasn’t to blame for what happened in the third period. Vaakanainen and Schneider struggled mightily. Parssinen’s ill-advised penalty opened the door. Since coming over from Colorado in the Ryan Lindgren trade, he’s been ineffective. Laviolette finally sat him out against the Blue Jackets in favor of Brett Berard, who brings more to the table.
In falling to the Senators, the Rangers blew a golden opportunity to vault ahead of idle Columbus and into the first wild card position. Instead, they entered Sunday trailing the Sens by a point and were on the outside looking in with the Blue Jackets having played one fewer game despite being tied in points. That made tonight’s game at 33rd and 7th pretty important.
On home ice facing a division rival they will be battling with until the final day of the season, they embarrassed themselves by losing 7-3 to fall two in back of the Blue Jackets with 18 games remaining. It didn’t have to be this way. But defense and checking were both optional at Madison Square Garden.
With the game still scoreless, Zach Werenski set up Justin Danforth to give the Blue Jackets the lead. The play started due to a bad turnover by Cuylle inside the Columbus zone. Normally a smarter player who plays north/south, he made an East/West pass inside the blue line that led to Werenski taking a Danforth drop pass and passing the puck back to Danforth for an easy finish. The defense pair of Soucy and Zac Jones got victimized. Soucy had trouble with Werenski’s speed, which led to Jones overcompensating for his partner. He went to Werenski, who had an easy passing lane for Danforth’s goal. To put it mildly, the third pair had a tough night.
Despite falling behind, the Rangers played a pretty good first period. They had more puck possession and outshot the Blue Jackets 9-4. In fact, it was the fourth line of Brodzinski, Berard, and Matt Rempe who dominated most of their shifts by spending time in the Jackets’ end. In particular, Rempe used his size and strength to create opportunities. His rapid improvement over the past month has been noticeable. He’s making more plays with the puck and doing a better job on the forecheck. Rempe now resembles an effective hockey player who the coaching staff trusts enough to play him more consistently.
Back in the lineup for Parssinen, Berard was a thorn in the side of the Jackets. He drew a pair of interference penalties. The first came on Kent Johnson, who delivered a hit that sent Berard into the Blue Jackets door. It really wasn’t interference due to Berard having the puck. It was more of a boarding, which is how Sam Rosen described it on the MSG broadcast.
If there’s been a bugaboo since Adam Fox went down, it’s been on the power play. The Rangers haven’t been able to get much going on it. Even with Laviolette finally coming to his senses by sticking Chris Kreider back on the top unit, they went 0-for-4. Kreider came the closest on one, but Daniil Tarasov denied him twice, including on a juicy rebound. Kreider just returned yesterday after missing six games due to an upper-body injury. He’s looked better and seems to be skating with more speed and is finishing checks. If he’s healthier, that could bode well for the team down the stretch.
The Rangers drew even thanks to executing on an offensive draw that was created by Rempe forcing Dante Fabbro to take an icing late in the period. With a chance to take advantage, Laviolette wisely got the Panarin unit out. Following a Trocheck faceoff win, Lafreniere had his shot pass tipped in by Panarin to give him goals in five straight games. It was an excellent play by all three to get the game tied headed to the locker room. Panarin is up to 28 goals. He’s back to playing like the star he is.
Following the goal, Berard drew a second interference minor. It didn’t matter because of how ineffective the man-advantage has been. To paraphrase what Laviolette said in the postgame, they are getting shots. But they’re either not connecting, going wide, or being saved. It’s not like they didn’t have chances. Tarasov made 10 saves when his team was shorthanded. That included robbing Zibanejad from in tight. He got stronger as the game went on.
At the start of the second period, the Rangers looked like they took a nap. With the Blue Jackets coming in with more speed, they took advantage quickly to suddenly grab a 3-1 lead. Adam Fantilli tallied twice within a 26-second span. On the first one, he took advantage of Borgen falling down inside the Blue Jackets’ blue line to start a two-on-one. Fantilli’s wrist shot fooled Jonathan Quick to put the Jackets ahead. On the next shift, Dmitri Voronkov found Fantilli left alone in front for his second of the game. Both Vaakanainen and Schneider were victimized on the goal.
For a while, it looked like the Jackets would run the Rangers out of the building. But they couldn’t handle prosperity. With Cuylle off for holding, it was the Rangers who then turned the tables by scoring a pair of shorthanded goals 42 seconds apart to tie the score. With Columbus getting sloppy in their own end, Zibanejad and Trocheck combined to set up Schneider for a shorthanded goal. Trocheck made a good pass across that Schneider drove upstairs for his fourth.
Some more follies allowed the Rangers to tie it. A turnover from Ivan Provorov was forced by Kreider, who poked the puck loose. He then worked a give and go with Zibanejad on a two on none rush. The passing was perfect with Zibanejad sliding it across for Kreider’s fourth shorthanded goal of the season. Despite missing time, he’s tied for second in shorthanded goals. Only Sam Reinhart has more with five. Most astonishing is that even though he’s not a good defensive player, Kreider has good hockey instincts on the penalty kill which make him dangerous shorthanded. No player has scored more shorthanded goals (13) since 2021-22.
With the Garden rocking, the Rangers had all the momentum but couldn’t get the next goal. If they had, it might have been a different headline. When he was called upon, Tarasov made the timely stops to keep the game tied. That included a save on Panarin, who was firing the puck from everywhere. He tied with Brodzinski for the team lead with five shots and had nine attempts.
As the second wore on, it was the Blue Jackets who got the better chances. Eventually, they went back ahead. On a brilliant play from Werenski, who should win the Norris and get some votes for the Hart, he found Mathieu Olivier in front with a great pass that he tipped in to put the Jackets up 4-3 with 2:57 remaining. While most of the ink goes to Cale Makar and Quinn Hughes when he’s healthy, Werenski deserves all the accolades for a special season. With two assists, he’s up to 68 points on the season. There isn’t a better defenseman in 2024-25 than him.
Trailing by one, the Rangers gave up a back breaking goal with 73 seconds remaining in the period. Another Cuylle turnover led to some more Blue Jackets transition. Fabbro scored to make it 5-3. On a late shift, Panarin had a good scoring opportunity stopped by Tarasov. He was instrumental in the third making 17 saves to prevent the Rangers from making it interesting.
Despite the Rangers piling up the shots in an inspired third, they couldn’t beat Tarasov. At even strength, it was the fourth line that generated the best looks. Laviolette made a switch by shifting Brennan Othmann onto the line and moving Berard onto the third line. Reunited with Brodzinski and Rempe, who he has good chemistry with, Othmann was more effective than he was with Sam Carrick and Kreider. Right now, the third line has become a problem. The Rangers lack a true third line center. It doesn’t matter if it’s Carrick or Brodzinski centering it. Parssinen isn’t the solution, either.
After some more strong work from Rempe down low that led to cheers, Brodzinski had two shots stopped by Tarasov, who finished with 32 saves. He was the story of the third, making more than half his stops.
The roof caved in on a bit of fluky goal from Johnson. On a good counter started by Olivier, who is an effective player, he had his initial shot stopped by Quick. But with the puck taking a funny hop in mid-air, Johnson went to bat it in. However, the puck was accidentally put in by Jones. It was a mess. Jones had the puck go off his glove and past a helpless Quick to make it 6-3 with less than 10 minutes remaining.
Fantilli then completed the hat trick less than two minutes later to put the game out of reach. A young power forward, it was his second career hat trick, with his first coming versus the Maple Leafs on Jan. 22. The 2023 third overall selection is starting to blossom into an emerging star. He doesn’t even turn 21 until October.
Less than a couple of minutes later, Borgen responded to a dirty hit from Luke Kunin on Trocheck. He boarded Trocheck from behind, leading to Borgen dropping the gloves and knocking down Kunin. Kunin received both boarding and roughing along with fighting for nine penalty minutes. Of course, Borgen got the instigator and a misconduct to go with fighting for 17 penalty minutes. So, that was it for him.
Laviolette then lifted Quick for a six-on-four advantage. It didn’t matter. Tarasov made a pair of stops on Kreider and Zibanejad. For a below average backup goalie, he played extremely well. On the flip side, it was a tough one for Quick, who allowed a season high seven goals on 28 shots. While it wasn’t his best effort, this isn’t on him. It’s on how badly the Rangers broke down in their end. Combined with some really bad decision making, with Cuylle having his worst game, it wasn’t their night.
It’s easy to be aggravated about what transpired. But if you’ve followed this team closely, you already know who they are. When the going gets tough, they fold. Whether it’s blowing leads like against the Avalanche twice, the Caps, and Senators. Or it’s falling apart like they did tonight against the Blue Jackets. This team doesn’t deserve to make the playoffs. They’re lucky the competition is so mediocre. I guess they’ll be rooting for Detroit to beat Ottawa on Monday night.
The Blue Jackets visit the Devils on Tuesday night. I fully expect them to win. The Rangers now must go on the road and visit the Jets on the same night. They will then visit the Wild this Thursday and conclude the three-game road trip in Columbus this Saturday. That will be the final regular season meeting between the Rangers and Jackets.
As good as he’s been, J.T. Miller’s disappeared lately. He was a minus-three and ineffective against the Blue Jackets. He only has one assist over the last three games. The Rangers need much more from Miller if they want to squeak in. Ditto for Lafreniere and Trocheck, with neither scoring any goals lately. Even though he’s putting up assists, Lafreniere hasn’t scored a goal since Feb. 2, going 12 consecutive games without one. That’s brutal. For the season, he has 14 goals. So, basically, he and Zibanejad have killed this team in the scoring department.
I don’t get the thinking with sitting out Calvin de Haan. He’s a better skating defenseman than Soucy, who struggled in his second game finishing minus-2. I’m not suggesting that he sit out. But Vaakanainen hasn’t exactly looked good defensively. But he plays with Schneider on the second pair. They really are a third pair getting second pair minutes. I preferred seeing de Haan with Jones, who didn’t have a good weekend, either. There’s no telling what Laviolette will do with the defense.
It’s disappointing to see the Rangers give such a disjointed effort. They must get back to defending better and playing responsibly. The schedule doesn’t get any better.
You must be logged in to post a comment.