For the first 19 minutes of play, the Rangers showed no signs of being outmatched by their archrival. In fact, they easily killed off a full two-minute 5-on-3 without giving up a shot, which drew some boos from the Devils crowd.
There was even a dominant forecheck created by the new line featuring the sizzling Alexis Lafreniere late in the opening period. But after Lafreniere came close to getting the first goal, a brutal J.T. Miller giveaway led directly to Evan Rodrigues scoring unassisted with just under 30 seconds left in an otherwise good period.
“I just fanned on it. I think I should’ve just ate it,” Miller said afterward in the visitors locker room.
That one gaffe was the turning point in a disastrous 7-1 blowout loss to the Devils at what’s now become the new House of Horrors for the Rangers. They self destructed in a mind-numbing second period that saw the Devils score three straight on Dylan Garand to chase him from the net. That marked the first time in his short career that he’s been pulled.
It only got worse from there, with the Devils padding their lead to 5-0 on a nifty solo effort from Luke Hughes, who recorded the first two-goal game of his NHL career in another easy win for the home side at The Prudential Center. Inexplicably, the Rangers play their worst hockey when they visit Newark. They’ve now dropped four straight games there in blowout fashion by getting outscored 22-4. Here’s the full breakdown that dates back to the 2024-25 season:
December 23, 2024 Rangers 0 Devils 5
April 5, 2025 Rangers 0 Devils 4
March 7, 2026 Rangers 3 Devils 6
October 15, 2026 Rangers 1 Devils 7
In fact, aside from sweeping the two games at The Rock in 2023-24, the Rangers have lost six of the last eight meetings against the Devils in enemy territory. That includes the brutal conclusion to a first round series defeat in Spring 2023. All six defeats have come by at least three goals, including four that were shutouts. If you include the two 4-0 losses to Akira Schmid, the Rangers have been outscored by a combined 30-4 in those games.
When it comes down to it, the Devils treat the rivalry with more disdain and intensity. Jack Hughes has said openly that he hates the Rangers. He then backs it up by putting up big numbers in almost every meeting. Ironically, he only had an assist last night. Instead, he got strong support from younger brother Luke, Rodriguez, Nico Hischier, Arseny Gritsyuk, Stefan Noesen, and Cody Glass. Almost every Devil contributed to their second straight win.
From a Rangers vantage point, it was a complete no show following Miller’s costly turnover. They got away from the well structured system they’ve had early success with. Ugly turnovers were a theme, along with bad goaltending. Garand was shaky following the Rodriguez goal. It showed in the second when he allowed three goals over a 4:21 span, which led to Spencer Martin replacing him.
Eightenen seconds into the period, a Luke Hughes shot deflected off the skate of Adam Fox past Garand to make it 2-0. The unlucky bounce was a bad break that gave the Devils some extra jump. After feeding Timo Meier for a one-timer in front, Hischier was able to steer in a loose puck that made it 3-0. On that one, Vladislav Gavrikov was caught out of position.
The fourth Devils goal was a result of another Miller miscue. After a good keep in by Tye Kartye, Miller turned over the puck due to some pressure from Dougie Hamilton. A great Jack Hughes pass led Gritsyuk in alone on Garand, who stopped him. With the Rangers scrambling back, Hamilton set up a strong Hughes shot that caromed out for an easy Gritsyuk put away to end Garand’s night. After allowing just four goals on 81 shots coming in, he gave up four on 13 shots.
Head coach Mike Sullivan was accurate when he pointed out that Garand wasn’t the problem on Thursday night. The Rangers were sloppy in front of him and they weren’t hard on pucks. There were far too many lost battles to the opportunistic Devils, who get most of their offense from transition. To their credit, they also improved their forecheck after the first period, which had shots in favor of them 6-5.
Even a timeout with his team falling behind 3-0 couldn’t prevent the Devils from blowing it open. Following the Gritsyuk tally, the younger Hughes added his second on a great solo effort by skating into open ice and going stick side on Martin for a 5-0 cushion. Oliver Bjorkstrand just watched as Hughes skated in for his third. It was indicative of how poorly the Rangers played.
If there was a positive, Pavel Dorofeyev finally scored his first goal in seven games to break Nico Daws’ shutout with under 12 minutes remaining in the third period. With the Rangers on the power play, Lafreniere set up a Fox wrist shot that Dorofeyev redirected for his second to make it 6-1. Hopefully, that will get him going. He’s a streaky player who can score in bunches. The Rangers need him to get hot.
Summing up a night of frustration, a Fox turnover in the neutral zone led directly to Glass getting one shorthanded by going through the wickets of Martin for the coup de grace. The effort from Glass was a noticeable difference to score that goal was a big difference between the two sides.
To be perfectly blunt, the Devils want treat these games like the playoffs. They get up for them because it’s ingrained from the start that the Rangers are universally hated by the organization and its fans. If you don’t think these games are circled on the calendar, you’re out of your mind.
Contrast that with how the Rangers approach them. There’s never any animosity shown towards a blood rival. There’s no direct quotes about the significance of playing these games. They don’t treat it the same. Despite how the fans feel about the rivalry, they provide nothing. Is it really a rivalry if it’s so onesided? At this point, I’m inclined to say, ‘No.’
They bring more to the table against the Islanders because they’re the number one rival. But why can’t they get up for the Devils? This isn’t the same roster as the past two years. They just shut down the Lightning for the second time this season. If you were to poll most Rangers fans, they’d probably say that the Lightning are a better team than the Devils.
It was truly disappointing. A game that most looked forward to watching, and it was over after the start of the second. Admittedly, I ran an errand and heard those first two goals on the radio. When it became 3-0, I stayed out to grab a couple of slices instead of coming home. What’s the point of watching? I knew where it was headed. As one close friend told me, “You didn’t miss much.”
The next time the Rangers see the Devils will be a day before my birthday on December 7. I won’t have any expectations. At least it’ll be played at Madison Square Garden. So far, they’re a perfect 5-0 at home.
By losing badly to New Jersey, they fell to 1-3 on the road. Next up is a visit to Columbus. Another team that seems to give them trouble away from MSG. Let’s see how they respond. If they do have the high character we’ve seen, which Sullivan referenced following last night, then hopefully the bad loss to the Devils is a one off. Expect Garand to be back in net.
THREE STARS
3rd Star Timo Meier, Devils set up a pair of goals, +2 in 14:30
2nd Star Evan Rodrigues, Devils goal and assist, +2 in 17:23
1st Star Luke Hughes, Devils first two-goal game of career, 5 SOG, +3 in 24:58
Cuylle Hit Leads to Kovacevic Challenging Him
When it was still competitive in a tightly played first period, there was some physicality from both sides. Meier had a couple of good hits for the Devils.
On the Rangers side, Will Cuylle caught Decan Chisholm with a solid check that sent him down. Despite a clean hit that didn’t have much impact, Jonathan Kovacevic challenged Cuylle.
The two squared off in a short bout that Cuylle took. Each received five minutes for fighting. Kovacevic didn’t receive an extra two due to tapping Cuylle before and waiting for him to respond.
Chmelar Goes Down After Returning
After sitting out the last game against Tampa, Jaroslav Chmelar returned to the lineup. He played with Justin Dowling and Bjorkstrand on the fourth line. On a goal allowed, he was caught chasing Luke Hughes from behind before he scored to make it 5-0.
In 12 shifts, Chmelar finished a minus-1 in 8:35 of ice time. Due to him not playing enough consistent minutes, the Rangers sent him down to the Wolf Pack earlier today. With Hartford visiting the Charlotte Checkers tonight and tomorrow for a pair of games this weekend, Chmelar will be able to play more than he has.
It’s the right move for his development. A similar decision to opting to send down Cole Beaudoin, who did nothing wrong in his first taste of the NHL.
In a corresponding move that I hinted at, Taylor Raddysh was recalled by the Rangers. The 28-year-old veteran forward can be trusted to play in a supporting role on the fourth line. In 68 games last season, Raddysh put up nine goals and 10 assists for 19 points.
You must be logged in to post a comment.